The history of producing genetically modified food can be traced back to
mid-19th century with Gregor Mendel who is considered to be the founder of science of genetics today.
Mendel's
observations paved way for the development of first genetically modified plant,
a tobacco plant resistant to an antibiotic. It was created in 1983. But a tomato paste which was modified, was sold
on supermarkets of the United Kingdom in 1996.
The European Union approved the importation and use of a kind of soya for
people and feed for animals in 1996.
What followed was a series of controversies associated with consumption
of genetically engineered food products, which made the masses believe that humans were reduced to mere guinea
pigs for this new technology.
Genetic research continued, and eventually many other food crops were
genetically modified to suit human requirements.
The total surface area of land cultivated to grow genetically modified
crops increased from 4.2 million acres in 1997 to 331 million acres in 2009.
The controversial history of this practice has kept it in spotlight over
the last fifteen years. It is mainly because of the conflicting research on their benefits and
dangers. It is wise to evaluate the pros and cons of these food products and opt
for a safe way out, even if it means abstaining from their consumption.
GMOs: What is genetic modification?
GMOs:
Genetically modified foods are food products which are obtained from
genetically modified organisms (GMOs) - both
plants as well as animals. In this process, the said organisms are subjected
to modification by making specific changes to their DNA by means of genetic
engineering. This involves either insertion or deletion of genes. Genetic
engineering has been one of the major achievements in the field of biology, and
the use of same for production of food is no doubt tempting.
A YOU TUBE VIDEO: GMO A GO GO
This new animated cartoon covers
all the basics on why GMOs can be dangerous.
Agriculture
faces serious challenges in the years ahead
From a rapidly growing global population that will
put increasing strain on the world’s food supply, to climate change and its
effect on water availability and arable land, to concerns about the environment
and biodiversity.
Europe can help the world face these challenges. How?
Europe can help by using less water, increasing our land’s
productivity to help fight global food insecurity, exploiting less land in
other countries for our food needs, and addressing the effects of climate
change.
But this can happen only if policymakers give farmers the tools
they need to compete and survive in a changing world. The technologies offered
by crop science and genetic engineering have a long history of improving
agriculture and play a critical role in addressing the challenges of today and
tomorrow. GM crops are not the only answer, but their environmental benefits
and higher yields make them an option that farmers should have the freedom to
choose.
Concerns about possible negative effects on health and the
environment have proven to be unfounded. Around the world, 15.4 million farmers
are planting GM crops on 148 million hectares. But Europe has been slow to
embrace the technology.
Time and technology are moving on
– is Europe ready to move with them?
Agricultural
Science
Plants have been genetically modified in order to
increase crop yields and decrease susceptibility to pests. By far the most
common genetic modification to these plants is the addition of a gene that
codes for a pesticide. Pesticides kill microbes and insects by inhibiting their
living enzymes. Apparently our government believes that pesticides won't affect
our enzymes or that we can wash off the pesticides from the plant foods that
contain them.
When it comes to genetic modification, this is one
thing that cannot be washed off because the insecticides are already inside the
cells of the plants.
Watch a YOU TUBE video to see what it is.
"Genetic engineering: The world's greatest scam?"
"Genetic engineering" is a threat to food security,
especially in a changing climate. The introduction of genetically manipulated
organisms by choice or by accident grossly undermines sustainable agriculture
and in so doing, severely limits the choice of food we can eat.
Once GE plants are released into the environment, they
are out of control. If anything goes wrong - they are impossible to recall.
GE contamination threatens biodiversity respected as the
global heritage of humankind, and one of our world's fundamental keys to
survival.
Which GM Crops are grown around the world?
The main GM
crops in terms of hectarage are soya, maize, cotton and oilseed rape (canola).
Other GM crops that have been approved around the world include sugarbeet, alfalfa,
papaya, squash, poplar, tomato, banana, sweet pepper, potato, rice and various
ornamental flowers.
GM
worldwide
How
many farmers plant GM worldwide?
A
record 15.4 million farmers grew GM crops in 2010, up from 14 million farmers in
2009. Worldwide, 148 million hectares were planted with GM crops in 29
countries – an 87-fold increase since they were introduced in 1996. This is
about the same size as the territories of Spain, Germany and France combined.
In millions of ha.
In millions of ha.
Estimate
of future numbers of GM crops worldwide
Current
numbers and estimations of future numbers of GM crops
GM corn grown in
Spain
Planting
statistics for EU countries
In 2010, eight European countries planted GM crops on
a total of 91,438 ha.
Spain
76,575 hectares Bt MAIZE
Portugal
4,868 hectares Bt MAIZE
Poland
3,000 hectares Bt MAIZE
Slovakia
1,248 hectares Bt MAIZE
Romania
822 hectares Bt MAIZE
Czech Republic
4,680 hectares Bt
Sweden
MAIZE 80 hectares
GM POTATO
Germany
15 hectares GM POTATO
Why do we need to "improve"
plants?
Planting
statistics for EU countries
In 2010, eight European countries planted GM crops on
a total of 91,438 ha.
Spain
|
76,575 hectares Bt MAIZE
|
Portugal
|
4,868 hectares Bt MAIZE
|
Poland
|
3,000 hectares Bt MAIZE
|
Slovakia
|
1,248 hectares Bt MAIZE
|
Romania
|
822 hectares Bt MAIZE
|
Czech Republic
|
4,680 hectares Bt
|
Sweden
|
MAIZE 80 hectares
GM POTATO
|
Germany
|
15 hectares GM POTATO
|
Why do we need to "improve"
plants?
Problems that the world faces:
- water
shortages and salination of existing water suplies
- climate
change by developing crops that can resist floods or drought.
- consumers’ Health by producing better cooking oils
that don’t include trans fats and/or have higher levels of beneficial Omega-3
oils.
The Advantages and Disadvantages of Genetically Modified Food
The number of countries growing genetically modified crops has increased in recent years causing much debate over the safety of these products. Supporters claim it will feed the world and promote better health and ecological welfare. While others believe the food contains risks to human health.
Genetically
modified organisms (GMO) include crops, vegetables and fruit that have been
created using genetic engineering methods. Scientists combine desirable genes
from various species to create new genetically-altered crosses with enhanced
nutritional, productive and ecological value. This differs from traditional
breeding in that genetic transference between unrelated species does not occur
biologically in nature.
The
process of combining inter-species genes, which is called recombinant DNA
technology, does not have the checks and balances that are imposed by nature in
traditional breeding. Because of this there is a risk of genetic instability. This
means that no one can make any accurate predictions about the long-term effects
of GMOs on human beings and the environment.
Food is an emotional topic. It
matters a great deal to all of us.
We are what we eat after all
Advantages of GMO
- Crops are more productive and have a larger yield
- Offer more nutritional value and better flavour
- A possibility that they could eliminate allergy-causing properties in some foods
- Inbuilt resistance to pests, weeds and disease
- More capable of thriving in regions with poor soil or adverse climates
- More environment friendly as they require less herbicides and pesticides
- Foods are more resistant and stay ripe for longer so they can be shipped long distances or kept on shop shelves for longer periods
- As more GMO crops can be grown on relatively small parcels of land, they are an answer to feeding growing world populations
Corporations insist that:
- Genetically modified foods are safe.
Changing a few genes here and there does not make a crop toxic or
dangerous.
- Why shouldn't we alter nature to meet our needs? There are many natural organisms that human beings have transformed to serve their purpose.
Dangers of GMO
- Scientists can choose which genes to manipulate, but they don't yet know where in the DNA to precisely insert these genes and they have no way of controlling gene expression. Genes don't work in isolation, changing a few could change the whole picture, with unpredictable results.
- The use of genetically modified food should not be encouraged without research into the risks.
- Not labelling is wrong and unfair to the consumers who should have the right to know what they are buying so they can decide for themselves whether they want to buy the food or not. Even if health safety factors are not an issue, some people might have moral or religious objections. They should not have to eat GMOs if they don't want to.
- Genetically modified crops pose a risk to food diversity as the plants are much more dominant.
- Herbicide-resistant and pesticide-resistant crops could give rise to super-weeds and super-pests that would need newer, stronger chemicals to destroy them.
- GMO crops cross-pollinate with nearby non-GMO plants and could create ecological problems. If this were to happen with GMO foods containing vaccines, antibiotics, contraceptives and so on, it would very well turn into a human health nightmare.
- The claim of ending world hunger with GMOs is false. World hunger is not caused by a shortage of food production, but by sheer mismanagement, and lack of access to food brought about by various social, financial and political causes.
- GMO technology companies patent their crops and also engineer crops so that harvested grain germs are incapable of developing. This is not empowering to impoverished Third World farmers, who cannot save seeds for replanting and have to buy expensive seeds from the companies every year. The new technology also interferes with traditional agricultural methods which may be more suited to local environments.
- GMOs are not the answer to world hunger and health. Instead we should focus on improving organic agricultural practices which are kinder to the earth and healthier for humans.
Why are GMOs Bad?
For Producer
Majority of
the GM seeds are produced by private enterprises and thus are patented. A
patent prevent producer from saving and exchanging seeds, therefore undermining
the farmers’ right on seeds. The producer has to buy fresh seeds for every
cultivation season. In effect, producer loses seed sovereignty and become
dependent on Multinational Corporations. GM seeds also increase the cost of
production. As patented seeds carry a considerable amount as royalty fees which
increases the market price. Moreover, GM seeds requires chemical pesticides and
fertilizers as suggested by the inventors to produce the desired yield- an
factor which could further increases the cost of production.
For Consumers
GM crops can
produce adverse health impact on both humans and livestock. The foreign gene in
the GMO might behave differently in contexts other than the one they were taken
from. This can give rise to severe allergic reactions. There were reports on
adverse impact of Bt cotton on human health (skin and eye allergies) from
Madhya Pradesh and on livestock (cattle deaths) from Andhra Pradesh in India.
GM crops can contaminate non GM varieties through cross pollination. Thereby
spreading their unknown side effects to nearby crop. Moreover, the health
implications related to the long term consumption of GM foods remains largely
unknown.
Warning!
Medical specialists are
concerned about the effects and consequences
of using transgenic foods. Laboratory studies warn
as dangerous transgenic foods and products.
Other GM threats
Apparently overnight biofuels became a GM success story of sustainable, economical, clean, safe, environmentally friendly alternative to oil, providing the solution to our energy problems and global warming. What the biotech industry doesn't want to know is the uncomfortable conclusions scientists have come to about biofuels.
What side of the argument do you fall on?
Cartoon: How
are GM crops made?
Are genetically modified food crops
safe?
These
two rates are littermates, both 19 days old, the larger one fed standard rat
chow, the smaller one also fed genetically modified soy.
H'mm - GM foods are safe?
A doctor
says: "We now have an epidemic of chronic non-communicable diseases in the
world. This includes diabetes, obesity, and cardiovascular disease among
others. As a medical doctor with a keen interest in nutrition it strikes me as quite
a coincidence that this is occurring and escalating rapidly just a few decades
after we began introducing, and widely distributing genetically modified foods
into the diet of the world's people".
Genetically Modified Food May Be Why
You're Fat
If you
feed a rat a lot of modified corn, guess what happens? It gets a lot bigger
than the rats that just eat regular corn. Do you want to be that fat rat?
In another study, researchers fed GM food to salmon
and compared them to salmon that ate non-GM food.
The
result: the GM food-gobbling salmon got bigger, ate more, developed a different
intestinal microstructure, lost some of their protein-digesting ability, and
ended up with immune system changes.
Unfortunately, the production of GM food is growing by
leaps and bounds throughout the world to match pace with the rising statistics
of diseases plaguing the global population. It has even reached the baby food
you have been gladly feeding your little ones.
Ways to Avoid
Eating Genetically Modified Foods
GMO does more harm
than good to your body.
"ADOPT GREEN
LIVING"
This can be easily done by paying attention to food labels.
Refrain from any unnecessary use of antibiotics by switching to alternate
medicine for easily curable health ailments. Also, avoid consuming chewable
vitamin tablets, specifically vitamin C. Cross out margarine from your grocery
list entirely! Favour butter instead. Switch from cow milk to goat milk and its
dairy products. You can even satisfy your cravings for corn by going for sweet
corn as only 3% to 5% of it is genetically modified.
You can now breathe a sigh of relief because your popcorn is also safe from
GMOs. If any poultry products say "100% grass fed" on the label, it
is a safe bet to buy them too.
- Soy and its
derivates
- Beet sugar
- Papayas
(from Hawaii)
-
Canola
-
Cotton
-
Cow milk and its derivates
-
Zucchini/Yellow Squash
-
Conventional Meat
-
Corn
-
Margarine
Substitute Sugar
Since
sugar is derived from GM beets, it would be a wise decision for your health to
substitute sugar with other natural sweeteners such as honey, maple syrup and
molasses.
Make sure you get your hands only
on organic honey. Avoid artificial sweeteners at all costs.
Diet
foods, candies and pre-packaged desserts are also big culprits.
There is
nothing you would be losing out by substituting because it contains absolutely
no nutrients.
Shop Smart
· Textured
vegetable protein
· Dextrose
· Maltodextrin
· Glucose,
Fructose
· GLUTEN
· Citric
acid
· Lactic
acid
This can be easily done by
paying attention to food labels. Also, avoid consuming chewable vitamin
tablets, specifically vitamin C.
This is a YOU TUBE video about how
to know which foods are GMOs.
Ethical, moral and religious concerns about GMOs
-
-
-
-
-
Farming From the Farmers' Point of View
Activists
frequently say that everyone should be eating organic food because it is better for people's
health and the environment. However, we wondered about organic farming from the
farmers' point of view.
Gabriela,
4th generation farmer says “GM crops are a way to keep farmers on their land
in Europe. If we don’t have more GM crops, we will become less competitive and
have to import more food as well as use less sustainable farming practices.”
Maotang,
Cotton farmer says: “As more and more modern technology products are used by farmers
and our income increased quite a lot, in my community, farmers do not lack food
and clothes anymore. You cannot find a child who cannot afford their education
anymore.”
David says: “I think there is a big future with
GM crops, but if we don’t get a move on, Europe risks denying European farmers
access to the biggest environmental advance that we have seen in the last 20-30
years, and at a time when we really need it. I for one would like to grow GM
crops again given the opportunity”.
Karim
says: “We experienced a parasite problem in 1987-1988. This was the year when
people treated their crops with pesticides up to 18 times. And since that year,
when you grow cotton, you put it in the ground and you are worried. You
couldn’t even sleep when you plant cotton because you don’t know if you can
cope with the parasites. But with GMOs, when you plant, now you can sleep.”
Carlos says:
“Biotechnology has delivered increased productivity, reduced costs and
better soil management. GM seeds make soil management easier, they work well
with the direct seeding technique and help to better control pests compared to
conventional varieties.”
Why do 15.4 million farmers choose to plant
these crops on 148 million hectares worldwide?
Farmers choose to plant these crops because
they benefit from the technology.
Consumer Attitude
towards Geneticlly Modified Foods:
How strongly, if at all, do you support or
oppose GM foods?
Shopper beliefs about GM foods and health
Conclusion
The production gain and the reduced production cost have
been proven many times through practical application. The implications of GM
foods in economic improvement are quite impressive and encouraging. The
concerns regarding the safety of these GM foods however are inconclusive in
studies. So the benefits of these GMOs seem to be a welcome change to a
struggling economy and defiantly deserve a chance to prove their worth. On the
other hand the possible harmful effects are enough to unsettle ones nerves. But
are as of now just that, possible but unproven.
GM Regulations in EUROPE
GMOs cannot be put on
a market without prior EU approval. The EU approval system is recognized as one
of the most stringent in the world.
What is the approval process of GMOs in the European Union?
1.
Risk assessment.
2.
When the European Food Safety Authority has completed the safety assessment,
it's necessary to form the basis of a Draft Decision for approval by the
European Commission.
3.
Post-released monitoring, traceability and labeling.
4.
Public information: throughout the approval process.
5.
Subsidiarity.
6.
Compliance with international trade rules.
How long do applications take and what do they cost?
It takes on average almost 4 years for a GM import
approval to be completed in Europe. Costs for applicant companies arise mainly
from the large number of studies required and vary from 7 million to 15 million
per crop.
Is
there an impact on innovation?
It has been estimated that European farmers could
increase their annual revenues by up to nearly 1 billion if they were allowed
to cultivate GM crops, such as maize, cotton, soybeans, oilseed rape, and sugar
beets.
How
is the safety of GM products assessed in the EU?
In the EU, this task is carried out by the EFSA, whose
panel of independent scientific experts cooperates 35 closely with national
authorities on food safety. Only products that have been deemed safe are
allowed to reach the market.
How
is choice for consumers and farmers guaranteed?
For farmers, choice is guaranteed through coexistence
measures for organic, GM and conventional crops. Across the EU, co-existence
measures have been very successful.
Labelling is mandatory within the EU for all food and
feed products consisting of, containing, or obtained from GM plants when this
is above 0.9% of that ingredient. This allows consumers to make an informed
choice.
DID YOU KNOW...?
If EU farmers were allowed to grow GM crops,
Europe’s economy could be boosted by 443 and 929 million each year.
WHICH GMOs CAN
BE CULTIVATED IN EU?
Just two GM CROPS can be cultivated in EU.
-
MON810: a type
of maize that helps fight off pests.
-
AMFLORA: several member states have issued bans on cultivation of one or both of these crops approved at EU level.
A
total of 36 GM crops were approved for imports and processing and for food and
feed in Europe. More than a half of these were of GM maize. Other
includes:
- Soybeens
- Rapessed
- Sugarbeet
- Cotton
GMO-Free Crops in Spain
There are
initiatives in Cataluña where several organizations are asking for a GMO-free
Cataluña. In particular an important catalan farmers union, Unio de Pagesos,
have asked the regional government on 9th March to declare Cataluña GMO-free.
Enforcement in Scotland
Powers to regulate the deliberate
release of GMOs of the Environmental Protection were devolved to the administration
for Scotland in 1999.
In Scotland, three sets of domestic
regulations implement the EU regulations, by granting powers to authorised
officers for enforcement, and creating penalties for non compliance.
(SASA) Science and Advice for Scottish
Agriculture is responsible for ensuring compliance with the regulations
governing the deliberate release into the environment of GMOs in Scotland. This is what they do:
GMO-Free Areas
in the EU September 2012
Great Sentences
about GMO to be remembered.
Words
related to GMOs:
antibiotics = medicine that is used to kill bacteria
apply =here: to work with
avoid = keep away from
beetle =an insect with a round hard black back
biodiversity = many plants and animals that live in a place
bug =a small insect, like a beetle
clover = a small plant with three or four leaves
compost =a mixture of dead plants and leaves that are
put on the soil to make it better
conventional = a method that has been used for a long time
crop = a plant like wheat or rice
that we use as food
crop rotation = you change the crops you grow
every year to save the quality of the soil
dairy products = products that come from a
cow, like milk and butter
enrich = to make better
environment = the world around us
fertilizer = material that is put into the ground to make
plants grow
forbid = not allow
graze = to eat grass in a field
growth hormone = a chemical that makes you
grow
herbicide = a chemical you use to kill unwanted plants
in the long term = not in the next few days or weeks , but in the
next years
insecticide = a chemical that you kill
insects with
manure = waste materials from animals
marketing = advertising and selling of a product
monoculture = to grow the same plants every year
nutrient =a chemical or food that gives
us what we need to grow
organic = made in a natural way ,
without chemicals
organic farming = growing food without using
chemicals
organic matter = material that comes from
living things
pasture = field
pest = a small animal or insect that
destroys plants or crops
pesticide = a chemical substance that you use to kill
insects and small animals that destroy crops
pollution =the situation of making air and water dirty
preserve = save
prevent = stop
raise = to feed animals and sell them as food
rely on =depend on, need
residue = rest; what is left over
row =in a line
soil = the top layer of the earth on
which plants grow
starvation = hunger
straw =dried stems of plants that are used for
making baskets, hats and other things
wasp = a black and yellow insect that can sting you
weaken = to make weaker
weed = wild plant that grows between other crops
widespread = common
What side of the argument do you fall on?
H'mm - GM foods are safe?
A doctor
says: "We now have an epidemic of chronic non-communicable diseases in the
world. This includes diabetes, obesity, and cardiovascular disease among
others. As a medical doctor with a keen interest in nutrition it strikes me as quite
a coincidence that this is occurring and escalating rapidly just a few decades
after we began introducing, and widely distributing genetically modified foods
into the diet of the world's people".
Genetically Modified Food May Be Why You're Fat
Ways to Avoid
Eating Genetically Modified Foods
Substitute Sugar
Diet
foods, candies and pre-packaged desserts are also big culprits.
There is nothing you would be losing out by substituting because it contains absolutely no nutrients.
There is nothing you would be losing out by substituting because it contains absolutely no nutrients.
How strongly, if at all, do you support or oppose GM foods?
WHICH GMOs CAN BE CULTIVATED IN EU?
- MON810: a type of maize that helps fight off pests.
- AMFLORA: several member states have issued bans on cultivation of one or both of these crops approved at EU level.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Words related to GMOs:
antibiotics = medicine that is used to kill bacteria
apply =here: to work with
avoid = keep away from
beetle =an insect with a round hard black back
biodiversity = many plants and animals that live in a place
bug =a small insect, like a beetle
clover = a small plant with three or four leaves
compost =a mixture of dead plants and leaves that are
put on the soil to make it better
conventional = a method that has been used for a long time
crop = a plant like wheat or rice
that we use as food
crop rotation = you change the crops you grow
every year to save the quality of the soil
dairy products = products that come from a
cow, like milk and butter
enrich = to make better
environment = the world around us
fertilizer = material that is put into the ground to make
plants grow
forbid = not allow
graze = to eat grass in a field
growth hormone = a chemical that makes you
grow
herbicide = a chemical you use to kill unwanted plants
in the long term = not in the next few days or weeks , but in the
next years
insecticide = a chemical that you kill
insects with
manure = waste materials from animals
|
nutrient =a chemical or food that gives
us what we need to grow
organic = made in a natural way ,
without chemicals
organic farming = growing food without using
chemicals
organic matter = material that comes from
living things
pasture = field
pest = a small animal or insect that
destroys plants or crops
pesticide = a chemical substance that you use to kill
insects and small animals that destroy crops
pollution =the situation of making air and water dirty
preserve = save
prevent = stop
raise = to feed animals and sell them as food
rely on =depend on, need
residue = rest; what is left over
row =in a line
soil = the top layer of the earth on
which plants grow
starvation = hunger
straw =dried stems of plants that are used for
making baskets, hats and other things
wasp = a black and yellow insect that can sting you
weaken = to make weaker
weed = wild plant that grows between other crops
widespread = common
|